Home / Guides / EU Machinery Regulation

Market surveillance, formal non-compliance and penalties under Machinery Regulation 2023/1230

What happens when an authority looks at your machine after 20 January 2027: the paperwork failures it can act on without showing any risk (Article 46), the procedure for products presenting a risk (Articles 43 to 45), who sets the penalties (Article 50) and what to keep ready.

Written by Proxom Engineering Ltd, a UK mechanical design engineering company. Checked on 20 November 2026 against the text of Regulation (EU) 2023/1230 on EUR-Lex (OJ text and consolidated version of 27 July 2026; Articles 43 to 46 are the same in both; the dates in Articles 50(2), 52(1) and 54 are those set by the corrigendum of 4 July 2023), Regulation (EU) 2019/1020 and Directive 2006/42/EC. We have not reviewed the national penalty laws of the Member States. The pending Omnibus IV amending proposal (2025/0134(COD)) was not adopted on that date; this guide follows the text in force. General information, not legal advice.

The short answer

  1. The Regulation sets no fines itself. Article 50 tells each Member State to lay down penalties for infringements by economic operators that are effective, proportionate and dissuasive and that may include criminal penalties for serious infringements. Member States had to notify their rules to the Commission by 20 October 2026 (date as corrected by corrigendum; 14 October 2026 in the original OJ text). Amounts and procedures are therefore national.
  2. Paperwork failures are enforced on their own. Article 46 lists 'formal non-compliance' that an authority can act on without any risk being shown: CE marking missing or wrongly affixed, notified body number wrong or missing, EU declaration of conformity not drawn up or not drawn up correctly, technical documentation not available or not complete, missing or wrong name and contact details, or any other administrative requirement of Article 10 or 13 not met. If it persists, the product can be restricted, prohibited, withdrawn or recalled.
  3. Products presenting a risk go through Article 43: the authority evaluates the product, requires corrective action within a period it sets, and if that does not happen ensures withdrawal, recall, prohibition or restriction, and informs the public, the Commission and the other Member States. The economic operator must take corrective action for all affected units it made available throughout the Union.
  4. Even a compliant machine can be the subject of measures if it still presents a risk to the health and safety of persons (Article 45).
  5. Dates. The Regulation as a whole applies from 20 January 2027 (Article 54). But under Article 52(1) the market surveillance chapter (Chapter VI, Articles 43 to 46) has applied since 19 July 2023, mutatis mutandis, to machinery placed on the market under Directive 2006/42/EC, instead of the Directive's safeguard clause (Article 11). Article 50(1), the duty on Member States to set penalty rules, applies from 20 October 2026.
  6. Authorities' minimum powers come from Regulation (EU) 2019/1020, Article 14(4): requiring documents and data in any form, access to embedded software where needed, supply-chain information, unannounced inspections, product samples (including under a cover identity) and imposing penalties.

The Article 46 formal non-compliance list

Paraphrased from the Official Journal text. These findings apply 'without prejudice to Article 43': an authority can require you to put an end to them whether or not the machine presents a risk. The right-hand column is our engineering suggestion of what to have ready, not wording from the Regulation.

ArticleFindingWhat to have ready
46(1)(a)The CE marking has been affixed in violation of Article 30 of Regulation (EC) No 765/2008 or Article 24 of the Regulation.A rating plate drawing showing the CE marking in the correct form and proportions, visible, legible and indelible. See our CE marking guide.
46(1)(b)The CE marking has not been affixed.A final-inspection check that the plate is on the machine before it ships.
46(1)(c)The identification number of the notified body involved in the production control phase has been affixed in violation of Article 24(3) or has not been affixed.Only if your route uses a notified body (Article 25(2) points (a)-(c) or 25(3) points (b)-(d)): its number after the CE marking. Module A machines carry no number. See our conformity assessment guide.
46(1)(d)The EU declaration of conformity has not been drawn up or has not been drawn up correctly.A signed declaration with every Annex V, Part A item, under Regulation (EU) 2023/1230, not the Directive. See our declaration guide.
46(1)(e)The technical documentation is either not available or not complete.An Annex IV, Part A file you can send quickly, with an index showing what is in it. See our Annex IV guide.
46(1)(f)The information referred to in Article 10(6) (manufacturer) or Article 13(3) (importer) is absent, false or incomplete: name, registered trade name or registered trade mark, postal address and a website, e-mail address or other digital contact.Plate or label artwork with the postal address and a digital contact; for imported machines, the importer's details too. See our importers guide.
46(1)(g)Any other administrative requirement provided for in Article 10 or Article 13 is not fulfilled.The rest of the Article 10 list: identification of model, year and serial number, instructions, declaration access, 10-year retention. See our Article 10 guide.
46(2)(a)-(d)Partly completed machinery: the EU declaration of incorporation not drawn up or not drawn up correctly; technical documentation not available or not complete; the information referred to in Article 11(5) (identification: designation, year of construction, model, series or type, batch or serial number) or Article 14(3) (importer's contact details) absent, false or incomplete; any other administrative requirement of Article 11 or 14 not fulfilled.The declaration of incorporation, the Annex IV, Part B file and the identification markings. See our partly completed machinery guide.

Where the non-compliance persists, the Member State takes all appropriate measures to restrict or prohibit making the product available on the market, or to ensure that it is recalled or withdrawn (Article 46(3)). In the Regulation, 'withdrawal' stops a product in the supply chain from being made available, and 'recall' gets back a product already made available to a user (Article 3, points (32) and (33)).

Products presenting a risk: the Article 43 and 44 procedure

StepWhat happensSource
1. Reason to believeMarket surveillance authorities have sufficient reason to believe a product presents a risk to the health or safety of persons (and, where appropriate, domestic animals or property, and, where applicable, the environment). They evaluate it against all relevant requirements; the economic operators must cooperate.Article 43(1)
2. Corrective actionIf the product does not comply, the authority requires the relevant economic operator, without delay, to take appropriate and proportionate corrective action within a reasonable period, to end the non-compliance or eliminate the hazard (or, if that is not possible, minimise the risk). The notified body concerned is informed.Article 43(1); corrective actions listed in Article 16(3) of Regulation (EU) 2019/1020
3. Union-wideIf the non-compliance is not restricted to one country, the Commission and the other Member States are informed. The economic operator must take corrective action for all products concerned that it made available throughout the Union.Article 43(2)-(3)
4. MeasuresIf the operator does not act in time, or the non-compliance or risk persists, the authority ensures that the product is withdrawn or recalled, or that making it available is prohibited or restricted, and informs the public, the Commission and the other Member States without delay. The notice says whether the cause is the essential requirements of Annex III or shortcomings in harmonised standards or common specifications.Article 43(4)-(5)
5. ObjectionsOther Member States report their own measures and any objections. If no Member State or the Commission objects within three months, a provisional measure is deemed justified; Member States then take restrictive measures without delay.Article 43(6)-(8)
6. Union safeguardIf objections are raised, or the Commission considers a national measure contrary to Union law, the Commission consults the Member States and the economic operators and decides by implementing act whether the measure is justified. If justified, all Member States take restrictive measures; if not, the measure is withdrawn.Article 44

Article 45 adds a separate route for a product that complies with Annex III but still presents a risk to the health and safety of persons: the Member State requires measures so that it no longer presents that risk, or its withdrawal or recall, and the Commission decides by implementing act whether the national measure is justified.

Penalties: Article 50

Article 50(1) obliges Member States to lay down the rules on penalties for infringements of the Regulation by economic operators and to make sure they are implemented. The penalties must be effective, proportionate and dissuasive and may include criminal penalties for serious infringements. Article 50(2) set the deadline for notifying those rules to the Commission: 20 October 2026 after the corrigendum (14 October 2026 in the original OJ text). Article 50(1) itself has applied since 20 October 2026 (Article 54(b)).

The Regulation gives no amounts; fines, offences and procedures are set by each Member State and can differ. Regulation (EU) 2019/1020 has the same general rule for the product laws it covers (Article 41). For your exposure, check the national law of each Member State where you place machines on the market; we do not summarise national penalties on this page.

Who the authority can turn to

Measures are addressed to the relevant economic operator, that is, whichever 'economic operator' (manufacturer, authorised representative, importer or distributor, Article 3, point (22)) is responsible for the non-compliance.

WhoWhat an authority may askSource
ManufacturerInformation and documents to demonstrate conformity, in a language easily understood by the authority, and cooperation on actions to eliminate risks; source code or programming logic on a reasoned request where relevant.Article 10(3) and (10)
ImporterKeeps a copy of the EU declaration of conformity for 10 years and ensures the technical documentation can be made available; provides documents on a reasoned request; its own name and contact details on the product (Article 13(3)) are on the Article 46 list.Article 13(8)-(9); Article 46(1)(f)
Authorised representativeThe mandate must at least allow it to keep the declaration and technical documentation available for at least 10 years, provide documents on a reasoned request and cooperate on actions to eliminate risks.Article 12(2)
DistributorMakes sure corrective action is taken for non-conforming products it made available, informs authorities where a product presents a risk, provides documents on a reasoned request and cooperates.Article 15; see our Article 15 guide
The EU-based operator for non-EU productsVerifies that the declaration and technical documentation exist, provides documents on a reasoned request, informs authorities about risks and cooperates on corrective action.Regulation (EU) 2019/1020, Article 4(3)

What changed from the Machinery Directive

TopicDirective 2006/42/ECRegulation (EU) 2023/1230
PenaltiesArticle 23: Member States lay down penalties for infringements of the national provisions adopted under the Directive; effective, proportionate and dissuasive; notified by 29 June 2008Article 50: penalties for infringements of the Regulation by economic operators; effective, proportionate and dissuasive; may include criminal penalties for serious infringements; notified by 20 October 2026 (corrected date)
Paperwork failuresArticle 17 'non-conformity of marking': CE marking on a product not covered, no CE marking and/or no EC declaration, misleading other markingsArticle 46: adds technical documentation not available or incomplete, a declaration not drawn up correctly, notified body number, name and contact details, and any other administrative requirement of Articles 10, 11, 13 and 14; separate list for partly completed machinery
Products presenting a riskArticle 11 safeguard clause: for CE-marked machinery with an EC declaration, used as intended or as reasonably foreseeable, that is liable to compromise health and safetyArticles 43-44: evaluation, corrective action within a set period, Union-wide corrective action by the economic operator, three-month objection period, Commission decision by implementing act. Since 19 July 2023 Chapter VI also applies, mutatis mutandis, to Directive machinery instead of Directive Article 11 (Article 52(1))
Compliant but risky productsNo separate articleArticle 45
Who must actThe manufacturer or his authorised representative (Article 17(2)); action against whoever affixed the CE marking (Article 11(5))The 'relevant economic operator': manufacturer, authorised representative, importer or distributor (Article 3(22))

What to do before 20 January 2027

  1. Make the Article 46 list your final document check for every machine shipped from 20 January 2027: CE marking, notified body number if any, declaration of conformity under 2023/1230, complete technical file, name, postal address and digital contact on the product.
  2. Be able to send the technical file quickly. 'Not available' is itself a formal non-compliance (Article 46(1)(e)); keep it complete, indexed and exportable, and keep it for at least 10 years (Article 10(3)).
  3. Know your units. Corrective action covers every affected unit you made available in the Union (Article 43(3)): keep a customer list by serial number and the supply-chain records of Article 19.
  4. Name one contact for authorities and decide who answers a reasoned request, in which language and how fast (Article 10(10)).
  5. Write a short corrective-action procedure: who decides on bringing a product into conformity, withdrawal or recall, and who informs which authority (Article 10(9)).
  6. Check your national penalty rules in each country where you sell; the Regulation leaves them to the Member States (Article 50).
  7. Non-EU builder? Make sure the EU-based economic operator for your machine has the declaration and can get the technical file on request (Regulation (EU) 2019/1020, Article 4). See our non-EU guide.

Questions

What are the penalties under Machinery Regulation 2023/1230?

The Regulation does not set amounts. Article 50 requires each Member State to lay down rules on penalties for infringements by economic operators, which must be effective, proportionate and dissuasive and may include criminal penalties for serious infringements. Member States had to notify the Commission of their rules by 20 October 2026 (corrected date). The amount and procedure therefore depend on the country; check the national law of each country where you sell.

What is formal non-compliance under the Machinery Regulation?

Article 46 lists administrative failures that an authority can act on in addition to, and without prejudice to, the risk procedure of Article 43: CE marking missing or affixed wrongly, the notified body number wrong or missing, the EU declaration of conformity not drawn up or not drawn up correctly, technical documentation not available or not complete, the manufacturer's or importer's name and contact details absent, false or incomplete, or any other administrative requirement of Article 10 or 13 not met. Paragraph 2 has a matching list for partly completed machinery.

Can a machine be recalled only because the paperwork is wrong?

Yes, if the problem persists. Article 46(3) says that where the formal non-compliance persists, the Member State takes all appropriate measures to restrict or prohibit the product being made available on the market or to ensure that it is recalled or withdrawn. The first step is a requirement to put an end to the non-compliance.

When do the enforcement articles apply?

For machinery and related products under the Regulation, from 20 January 2027 with the rest of the Regulation (Article 54, as corrected). For machinery placed on the market in conformity with Directive 2006/42/EC before that date, Article 52(1) says Member States must not impede its making available on the market, but Chapter VI of the Regulation (Articles 43 to 46) has applied to it since 19 July 2023, mutatis mutandis, instead of Article 11 of the Directive. Article 50(1) on national penalty rules applies from 20 October 2026. See our transition guide.

Which authority enforces the Machinery Regulation?

The market surveillance authorities of each Member State, as defined in Regulation (EU) 2019/1020 (Article 3, point (31) of the Regulation). Their minimum powers are in Article 14 of Regulation (EU) 2019/1020, including requesting documents and access to embedded software, unannounced inspections and the purchase of samples under a cover identity.

What corrective actions can an authority require?

Article 43(1) refers to Article 16(3) of Regulation (EU) 2019/1020, which lists among others: bringing the product into compliance (including rectifying formal non-compliance), preventing it from being made available, withdrawing or recalling it and alerting the public, destroying it or making it inoperable, and, where the risk arises only in certain conditions or for certain end users, adding warnings, setting prior conditions or alerting the end users at risk (Article 16(4)).

Can a machine that meets Annex III still be withdrawn?

Yes. Under Article 45, if a Member State finds that a product complies with the essential health and safety requirements of Annex III but still presents a risk to the health and safety of persons (and, where appropriate, domestic animals, property or the environment), it requires the economic operator to take measures so that it no longer presents that risk, or to withdraw or recall it.

Does a non-EU manufacturer face these measures?

The measures apply to the product and to the relevant economic operator. For a machine from outside the EU, the authority can address the EU-based economic operator under Article 4 of Regulation (EU) 2019/1020: the importer, an authorised representative mandated for those tasks or, failing those, a fulfilment service provider. The Article 46(1)(f) list includes the importer's own contact details. The non-EU manufacturer still has the Article 10 obligations.

Related guides: Manufacturer obligations (Article 10) · CE marking (Articles 23-24) · Declaration of conformity contents · Technical file under Annex IV · Importers and authorised representatives · Distributors (Article 15) · Transitional provisions (Article 52) · US and non-EU builders · Regulation vs Directive. We sell to businesses only; see Terms. Always verify against the official text of Regulation (EU) 2023/1230 on EUR-Lex.